Army Officer Evaluation Report Tips

Today, I’m going to share some Army OER Tips with you.

This article is for any Army Officer looking to improve their knowledge about writing accurate, effective and fair OERs.

I wrote and proofread a lot of OERs during my military career.

I was never an S1 or AG Officer, but I do have lots of experience with OERs.

I made some mistakes, did some things right, and learned some helpful tips in the process of handling all of those OERs.

My goal today is to transfer some of that knowledge to you.

Other Posts You Might Enjoy:

  1. U.S. Army Test and Evaluation Command (ATEC): 11 Cool Facts
  2. Army Commander’s Maintenance Evaluation Team (COMET) Program Overview
  3. Types of Mandatory Army Officer Evaluation Reports
  4. Secret Tip for Preparing Your Army NCOER or OER Support Form

That being said, here are my best tips.

# 1 Educate Yourself

I know, this should be common sense for most people.

Do yourself a favor and actually READ the regulations that talk about OERs.

Most of the things you will ever need to know are in the OER Regulations.

Another tip is to sit down with your S1 and pick their brain.

Take them out to lunch and ask them a bunch of questions.

You can also sit down with your rater or senior rater and see what advice they can share.

Another tip is to volunteer to give an OPD about OERs.

This will force you to do your research and educate yourself.

You can also talk to a trusted mentor and learn about OERs from them.

Just remember that it is your responsibility to educate yourself.

# 2 Keep Records of Your Achievements

Throughout the year, you should keep detailed records of your accomplishments.

You can do this weekly, monthly or quarterly.

Your goal is to record your major achievements so you can input them on your OER Support Form at a later date.

What I recommend is that you create your own OER file.

At the end of each month, write down your five to ten major accomplishments on a piece of paper and file it into your OER file.

Do this every month of your rating period and writing your OER Support Form will be very easy to do!

You see, it’s easy to forget what you accomplished during the rating period if you don’t write it down.

A year is a long time.

You would be amazed at what you accomplished in the past year if you have kept an accurate record of your accomplishments.

# 3 Draft Up Your OER Support Form

When it is time to prepare your Army OER Support Form, refer to your notes detailing your achievements.

When possible use numbers and quantifiable results.

Include operational readiness rates, Soldier promotions, extensions and any other quantifiable achievements.

Include the schools you attended, correspondence courses completed, civilian accomplishments and anything else you think is relevant.

These types of statements look much better on your Officer Evaluation Report than generic style achievements.

Ideally, you want to have a “working” OER Support Form at all times.

Once every quarter, update your OER Support Form.

Review your files with your accomplishments for the previous three months and put that information on your OER Support Form.

One month before your OER is due, spend a couple hours and tweak your Support Form.

Have a couple of peers, or a trusted mentor review it and give you feedback and guidance.

NEVER wait until the last minute to do your Support Form.

# 4 Prepare a First Draft OER for Your Supervisor

If you really want to position yourself for success, you should prepare a first draft OER for your supervisor ahead of time.

Tell them you did it to save them time (which you did).

Let them make any revisions or corrections to the Officer Evaluation Report as they see fit.

In most cases, they will appreciate the time you saved them and probably make very little changes to your OER.

This puts you in the driver’s seat and ensures your OER covers the key points that you want on it.

Encourage your subordinates to do the same for you.

Here are some sample Army OER Bullets.

# 5 Review the OER for Errors

Before signing your final OER (or anyone else’s), review it thoroughly.

Look for misspellings, errors and typos.

Make sure the administrative information is correct.

Make sure the APFT and HT/WT information is accurate on the OER.

If possible, review it once, set it down for a few hours, and then review it again before you sign it or approve it.

If possible, have someone else look it over one time to ensure it is accurate.

# 6 Address Discrepancies and Errors

If something is inaccurate or unjustified on the OER, talk with the rater or senior rater (or S1) about the comment and get it fixed, before you sign the final OER.

The rater can write whatever they want in their comments section, but if what they say is inaccurate, you have the right to address it.

You won’t always win the conversation, but it’s worth talking about.

# 7 Stay Proactive Throughout the Process

Other than educating yourself, this is the most important tip on this list.

Never, and I mean never, wait until the last minute to do your OER, or another person’s.

Stay proactive throughout the entire process.

OERs written on the last day before they are due are seldom very good or written well.

You need to put a lot of time, effort and thought into your OER (and your subordinates).

You need to give yourself time to write, edit and review OERs.

Doing it one day is a recipe for failure.

Know when the OERs are due and do your backwards planning to ensure you have a reasonable timeline for getting things done.

# 8 Appeal a Bad OER

If you ever receive a bad OER, that you feel is unjustified, you have the right to appeal the OER.

For instance, if you have a career ending OER, but never received any type of counseling (formal or informal) to back up the claims, you might consider appealing the OER.

Visit JAG.

Research the regulations and find out what your rights are to appeal the Officer Evaluation Report.

Wait 48 hours until you “cool off” and then make a logical decision about how to proceed.

Final Thoughts

Once again, it is your responsibility to manage your own Army Officer career.

One way to do that is to be proactive in the Officer Evaluation Report process.

More importantly, if you have subordinate officers working for you that you supervise, don’t forget to follow these steps with them.

One of your key responsibilities with your subordinates is to develop them and teach them new skills.

If you teach them what right looks like, they can do the same thing with their subordinates.

You should teach your subordinates about the OER process and make sure that the Officer Evaluation Report you prepare for them is accurate and justified.

In summary, the Army Officer Evaluation Report is the most important document in your personnel file.

Make sure you are proactive and follow the steps mentioned above, so you can get the best OER possible.

What are your thoughts?

What are your best tips about Army OERs?

Leave a comment and let us know.

I look forward to hearing from you.

chuck holmes

Chuck Holmes
Former Army Major (resigned)

Suggested Resources:

  • Drop the Belly Fat Today! Decrease cravings. Lose weight and feel great. Learn how.
  • The # 1 Health Product you need, but haven't heard of before! Get the info.
  • My Favorite Cup of Coffee. You've got to try this SMART COFFEE. Learn more.
  • The # 1 Home Business for 2024 & Beyond! Daily Pay. Take the free tour.
  • Get Paid to Shop Online. It's 100% free forever. Earn $30 per referral. Learn more.

7 thoughts on “Army Officer Evaluation Report Tips”

  1. A great article for any formal evaluation. The tip of the article for me is creating a draft of your evaluation for your supervisor. This has two benefits.
    1: Your supervisor will thank you for the time that you saved them; evaluations can really drain time out of your day.
    2: Most supervisors will use the bulk of the information you give them (assuming it's true lol) so you are doing yourself a favor.

  2. I enjoyed this article a lot. I believe that the most valuable piece of advice that you offer in it is to keep track of your own achievements. You should save those letters of congratulations (or reprimand), proof of education or training, and anything else that shows that you are meeting or exceeding your position requirements. This way, you come into your evaluation prepared and knowledgeable. Doing so will also keep you aware of how you are doing, so if there is an area that needs improvement, you can be proactive.

  3. You can’t expect anyone else to manage your career. Being proactive and planning ahead are so important to make sure you get promoted. We have to be our own cheerleaders. Your tips here for the OER are great. I have missed some of these myself. Keeping records along the way does make it easier to write the OER Support Form.

  4. These are some great OER Tips. I believe that all new Army Officers should take the time to learn what a “good” Officer Evaluation Report should look like. That way they can be prepared, document their achievements correctly and make sure they get the OER they deserve.

    1. Effie,

      I couldn’t agree with you more. It’s very important to know what to look for with OERs. All Officers should educate themselves about the rules governing the Army OER Process so they can manage their own career effectively and take care of the people working for them.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *